Published: 2026-02-01

Evaluasi Pelatihan Non-Teknis Menggunakan Model Kirkpatrick: Systematic Literature Review 2016–2025

DOI: 10.35870/jemsi.v12i1.5978

Nicholas Brima Pradhika
  • Nicholas Brima Pradhika: Universitas Paramadina
Front Cover JEMSI Volume 12 Nomor 1 Februari 2026
Article Metrics
Share:

Abstract

Training evaluation is a crucial component in assessing the effectiveness of human resource development programs, particularly non-technical training that emphasizes attitudes, behaviors, and values. This study aims to examine the application and effectiveness of the Kirkpatrick Four-Level Evaluation Model in the context of non-technical training through a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) approach. The research method employed an SLR based on the PRISMA guideline by analyzing 25 scholarly articles published between 2016 and 2025, obtained from both national and international databases. The results indicate that Level 1 (Reaction) and Level 2 (Learning) are the most dominantly applied evaluation levels, whereas the implementation of Level 3 (Behavior) and Level 4 (Results) remains relatively limited due to constraints in long-term observation and organizational data support. These findings confirm that the Kirkpatrick model remains relevant for evaluating non-technical training; however, it requires the strengthening of behavioral and results indicators to ensure that training impacts can be measured more comprehensively. This study provides practical implications for training providers in designing evaluations that are oriented toward behavioral change and medium-term impact.

Keywords

Kirkpatrick Model; Training Evaluation; Non-Technical Training; Systematic Literature Review; Soft Skills

Peer Review Process

This article has undergone a double-blind peer review process to ensure quality and impartiality.

Indexing Information

Discover where this journal is indexed at our indexing page.

Open Science Badges

This journal supports transparency in research and encourages authors to meet criteria for Open Science Badges.

How to Cite

Pradhika, N. B. (2026). Evaluasi Pelatihan Non-Teknis Menggunakan Model Kirkpatrick: Systematic Literature Review 2016–2025. JEMSI (Jurnal Ekonomi, Manajemen, Dan Akuntansi), 12(1), 777-789. https://doi.org/10.35870/jemsi.v12i1.5978
Article Information

This article has been peer-reviewed and published in the JEMSI (Jurnal Ekonomi, Manajemen, dan Akuntansi). The content is available under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

  • Issue: Vol. 12 No. 1 (2026)

  • Section: Articles

  • Published: 2026-02-01

AI Research Hub

This article is indexed and available through various AI-powered research tools and citation platforms. Our AI Research Hub ensures that scholarly work is discoverable, accessible, and easily integrated into the global research ecosystem.

Semantic Scholar Scite Dimensions Connected Papers
Scholarly Connection Platforms
Dimensions Dimensions Connected Papers Connected Papers Scite Scite Google Scholar Google Scholar Semantic Scholar Semantic Scholar Garuda Garuda Scilit Scilit Crossref Crossref BASE BASE Zenodo Zenodo Unpaywall Unpaywall OpenCitations OpenCitations
Author Biographies

No author biographies available.

References
  • Alsalamah, A., & Callinan, C. (2021). The Kirkpatrick model for training evaluation: Bibliometric analysis after 60 years (1959–2020). Industrial and Commercial Training, 54(1), 36–63. https://doi.org/10.1108/ICT-12-2020-0115.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Andriani, W. (2022). Penggunaan metode sistematik literatur review dalam penelitian ilmu sosiologi. Jurnal PTK dan Pendidikan, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.18592/ptk.v7i2.5632.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Cahapay, M. (2021). Kirkpatrick model: Its limitations as used in higher education evaluation. International Journal of Assessment Tools in Education, 8(1), 135–144. https://doi.org/10.21449/ijate.856143.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Cahyono, Y. R., & Gunawan, A. (2024). Pentingnya memiliki soft skill bagi calon pekerja sebagai keterampilan kesiapan kerja. Jurnal Ekonomi dan Bisnis Digital, 1.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Dian Nisa, M., Sakinah, R., Hariyani, L., Hastika Dewi, S., & Isa Anshori, M. (2025). The impact of internship on soft skills and hard skills to improve students’ work readiness. Journal of Transformational Human Resource Management, 1.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Dwiwarman, D. A. (2024). Strategi pengembangan sumber daya manusia melalui keterampilan soft skills dan hard skills. Jurnal Minfo Polgan, 13(2), 1538–1549. https://doi.org/10.33395/jmp.v13i2.14119.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Ermawan, A., & Saragih, E. H. (2022). Evaluasi dan penyempurnaan praktik pelatihan fire drill dengan 4 level Kirkpatrick pada Aston Priority Simatupang. Journal of Emerging Business Management and Entrepreneurship Studies, 2(1), 15–22. https://doi.org/10.34149/jebmes.v2i1.58.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Faizin, A., & Kusumaningrum, H. (2023). Review model-model evaluasi program untuk pendidikan dan pelatihan online. EduManajerial, 1(1), 42–54. https://doi.org/10.15408/em.v1i1.32245.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Friyadi, R., Zakir, S., & Ilmi, D. (2025). Evaluasi program daurah (pelatihan) tahsin di Markazul Quran. JUTEQ: Jurnal Teologi & Tafsir, 2, 169–177.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Haddaway, N. R., Page, M. J., Pritchard, C. C., & McGuinness, L. A. (2022). PRISMA2020: An R package and Shiny app for producing PRISMA 2020-compliant flow diagrams, with interactivity for optimised digital transparency and open synthesis. Campbell Systematic Reviews, 18(2), e1230. https://doi.org/10.1002/cl2.1230.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Haqiki Noviar, M., Syarif, H., Rahmawati, E., Kunci, K., Pelatihan, E., Kirkpatrick, M., Arsip, M., Pusbangkom, S., Legislatif, S., Jenderal, D., Ri, J., Jenderal, G., & Subroto, J. (2024). Penerapan model Kirkpatrick level reaksi untuk evaluasi program pelatihan manajemen arsip dinamis di Pusbangkom SDM Legislatif Setjen DPR RI. Jurnal Kewidyaiswaraan, 9(1).
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Hariyani, N. (2023). Efektivitas pelatihan literasi keuangan bagi rumah tangga petani. Jurnal AgroSainTa: Widyaiswara Mandiri Membangun Bangsa, 6(2), 37–44. https://doi.org/10.51589/ags.v6i2.3134.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Hidayat, R., Alam, B. P., Lutvaidah, U., & Pantau, P. (2023). Implementasi evaluasi model Kirkpatrick pada program pelatihan penggunaan EYD V SMK Broadcasting Mahardika. Abdi Jurnal Publikasi, 1(5), 436–441.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Hidayat, R., Rahman, F., Perkasa Alam, B., & Ikhwati, A. (2022). Implementasi evaluasi model Kirkpatrick pada program pelatihan teknik bercerita dongeng guru SDN Nagrak 01. Communnity Development Journal, 3(3), 1419–1425.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Irawan, A., Hidayah, H. N., & Wildah, A. (2021). Evaluasi pelatihan teknik penanaman cempaka berdasarkan teori The Four Levels Kirkpatrick. Jurnal Pendidikan Biologi, 12(2), 64–70. https://doi.org/10.17977/um052v12i2p64-70.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Ismailah, Suwela, N., & Bakhtiar, M. Y. (2024). Evaluasi pelatihan literasi digital menggunakan model Kirkpatrick level 1. JKDN, 4.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Isnaeni, B., & Sudrajat. (2022). Evaluasi pasca pelatihan menggunakan model Kirkpatrick (T. Yuliyanti, Ed.; Cetakan pertama). Deepublish.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Juniawan. (2023). Efektivitas metode e-learning pada pelatihan formulator tanaman obat sebagai pestisida nabati dalam meningkatkan kapasitas petugas pertanian. Jurnal Widyaiswara Indonesia, 4(1), 11–20.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Kirkpatrick, J., & Kirkpatrick, W. K. (2010). An introduction to the New World Kirkpatrick® Model.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Lutfiah, Y., Fatonah, U., & Ibn Khaldun, U. K. (2023). Evaluasi program content entrepreneurship menggunakan model Kirkpatrick. Dalam Seminar Nasional Teknologi Pendidikan (Vol. 3, No. 1).
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Mahfud, T., Setyawati, R., Kusuma, B. J., Dwiningrum, N. R., & Basri, B. (2023). Model evaluasi Kirkpatrick pada program Bina Desa: Penguatan bisnis kuliner kader Pemberdayaan Kesejahteraan Keluarga (PKK). Journal of Applied Community Engagement, 3(1), 41–54. https://doi.org/10.52158/jace.v3i1.631.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Mardani, A., Sitompul, S. S., & Mursyid. (n.d.). Evaluasi program manajemen menggunakan model Kirkpatrick pada laboratorium fisika.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Millia Windhy, A., & Naibaho, T. T. (2022). Evaluasi efektivitas pelatihan tematik padi lahan rawa dengan metode Kirkpatrick pembelajaran. Jurnal Ekonomi dan Agribisnis (JEPA), 1. https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.jepa.2022.006.01.1.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Muhammad, I. K., & Fakhruddin, M. (2022). Evaluasi program pelatihan model Kirkpatrick. CERMIN, 1(2).
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Naibaho, T. T. (2023). Efektivitas pelatihan kewirausahaan bagi petani wilayah program READSI di Kabupaten Sambas. Jurnal AgroSainTa: Widyaiswara Mandiri Membangun Bangsa, 6(2), 59–66. https://doi.org/10.51589/ags.v6i2.3123.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Nawawi, M. B. (2022). Evaluasi Kirkpatrick level I pelatihan communication skills di Balai Diklat Keuangan Malang. Jurnal Pembelajaran Inovatif, 5(1), 86–92. https://doi.org/10.21009/jpi.051.11.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Noe, R. A. (2017). Employee training and development. McGraw-Hill Education.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Nur Sofiana, A. (2025). Penerapan model Kirkpatrick dalam evaluasi program karantina tahfizh di Qur’an Learning Center Yogyakarta. IHSAN: Jurnal Pendidikan Islam.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Oentoro, K. (2020). Evaluasi model Kirkpatrick terhadap kegiatan Design Camp #1: Bamboo for creative millennials. Pengetahuan dan Perancangan Produk, 3(8), 277–284.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Oktaviana, L., Yanti, & Nengsih, K. (2023). Evaluasi model Kirkpatrick pada UMKM SIBA Rosella dalam meningkatkan kesejahteraan keluarga di Tanjung Enim. Jurnal Multimedia Dehasen, 2(2), 239–248.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Paul, J., & Criado, A. R. (2020). The art of writing literature review: What do we know and what do we need to know? International Business Review, 29(4), 101717. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ibusrev.2020.101717.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Pratiwi, N., & Supiana, I. (2021). Evaluasi program pemberdayaan perempuan melalui pelatihan menjahit di Sanggar Kegiatan Belajar (SKB) Ujung Pandang.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Rizki, M., Saputra, E. K., Haryani, D. S., & STIE Pembangunan Tanjungpinang. (2024). Evaluasi pelatihan effective communication dan public speaking STIE Pembangunan Tanjungpinang. EKOMA: Jurnal Ekonomi, 3(4).
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Rizqi, F., & Warih, W. C. (2025). Model evaluasi Kirkpatrick dalam program pembinaan kepribadian di Lapas Kelas IIA Serang. Al-Zayn: Jurnal Ilmu Sosial & Hukum, 3. https://doi.org/10.61104/alz.v3i4.2139.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Snyder, H. (2019). Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and guidelines. Journal of Business Research, 104, 333–339. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2019.07.039.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Sudarmika, P., Nurhaeni, N. L. P., Agustini, T. F., & Santyasa, I. W. (2023). Training evaluation for nurses and midwives using the Kirkpatrick model. International Journal of Health Sciences, 7(2), 53–66. https://doi.org/10.53730/ijhs.v7n2.14504.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Suhartati, T. (2022). Evaluasi program pendidikan pelatihan pembinaan ideologi Pancasila bagi guru menggunakan model Kirkpatrick. Educational Technology Journal, 2(1), 45–55.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Supriyono, Putra, M. T. P., & Putri, J. W. E. P. (2024). Pelatihan model manajemen pendidikan kewirausahaan santripreneur sekolah menengah kejuruan pada SMK Islam Kanigoro, Kabupaten Blitar, Jawa Timur. Jurnal Pengabdian Mandiri, 3.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Suranto, Widiarti, P. W., & Hastasari, C. (2019). Evaluasi program pelatihan keterampilan dasar komunikasi bagi siswa di SMKN 1 Godean Sleman. Jurnal Efisiensi: Kajian Ilmu Administrasi, 16.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Tamsuri, A. (2022). Literatur review penggunaan metode Kirkpatrick untuk evaluasi pelatihan di Indonesia. Jurnal Inovasi Penelitian, 2.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Triana, H., Wasitohadi, & Ismanto, B. (2020). Evaluasi program ekstrakurikuler pramuka sekolah menengah kejuruan. Jurnal Manajemen Pendidikan, 7, 184–197.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Widiastuti, S., Bachri, B. S., & Maureen, I. Y. (2023). The New World Kirkpatrick Model (NWKM) pada pelatihan mandiri implementasi Kurikulum Merdeka (IKM) melalui platform Merdeka Mengajar (PMM). Jurnal Ilmiah Mandala Education (JIME), 9(2), 2656–5862. https://doi.org/10.58258/jime.v9i1.5083.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Wong, A., Hang, P., Singh Sikarwar, T., Balqis, A., Nordin, B., Irwany, N., Rosley, B., Mudzaffar, N. B., Sofea, A., Shokri, B. M., Mui, D., & Kee, H. (2024). The impact of soft skills training on the behavior of multinational technology company employees. Asia Pacific Journal of Management and Education (APJME), 7(2), 71–86. https://doi.org/10.32535/apjme.v7i2.327.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
  • Zalukhu, T. J., Waruwu, M. H., Mendrofa, Y., & Telaumbanua, E. (2024). Implementasi strategi pelatihan dalam meningkatkan keterampilan non-teknis karyawan untuk memenuhi tuntutan bisnis dan mendorong inovasi pada PT PLN (Persero) UP3 Nias. JESYA, 7(2), 1694–1702. https://doi.org/10.36778/jesya.v7i2.1602.
    Google Scholar Scite Semantic Scholar Scilit Crossref Connected Papers
License & Copyright
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:

1. Copyright Retention and Open Access License

Authors retain copyright of their work and grant the journal non-exclusive right of first publication under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).

This license allows unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

2. Rights Granted Under CC BY 4.0

Under this license, readers are free to:

  • Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format
  • Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, including commercial use
  • No additional restrictions — the licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as long as license terms are followed

3. Attribution Requirements

All uses must include:

  • Proper citation of the original work
  • Link to the Creative Commons license
  • Indication if changes were made to the original work
  • No suggestion that the licensor endorses the user or their use

4. Additional Distribution Rights

Authors may:

  • Deposit the published version in institutional repositories
  • Share through academic social networks
  • Include in books, monographs, or other publications
  • Post on personal or institutional websites

Requirement: All additional distributions must maintain the CC BY 4.0 license and proper attribution.

5. Self-Archiving and Pre-Print Sharing

Authors are encouraged to:

  • Share pre-prints and post-prints online
  • Deposit in subject-specific repositories (e.g., arXiv, bioRxiv)
  • Engage in scholarly communication throughout the publication process

6. Open Access Commitment

This journal provides immediate open access to all content, supporting the global exchange of knowledge without financial, legal, or technical barriers.

Downloads